The U.S. Supreme Court’s decision to hear a case — Department of Justice v. McNutt — involving distilled spirits taxes and restrictions on at-home alcohol stills could have broad implications for other regulatory taxes and penalties, Gray Proctor writes for Bloomberg Tax.
The Supreme Court’s eventual decision in McNutt could help resolve a circuit split regarding whether a Reconstruction-era ban on home distilling is a “necessary and proper” exercise of Congress’ power to levy taxes.
The Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals found the law an unconstitutional use of Congress’ taxing power in McNutt, reasoning that banning home distilling both reduced tax revenue and deprived home distillers of the option to pay the tax on distilled spirits. However, the Sixth Circuit upheld the ban in a separate case — Ream v. Department of the Treasury — finding that the law's original purpose, which aimed to ensure that distillers could not hide stills in their homes to avoid paying taxes, was properly within Congress’ power. (The Supreme Court has not yet decided whether to also hear the Ream appeal.)
Beyond the implications for home distillers, Gray notes that McNutt gives the Supreme Court an opportunity to look more broadly at Congress’ power to raise revenue and/or support other policy goals through the use of the tax code.
Gray notes that Congress has imposed several taxes that are not intended to raise revenue, such as the Inflation Reduction Act of 2022’s excise tax on drug manufacturers that fail to reach negotiated agreements with the Department of Health and Human Services on a “fair price” for medications offered to Medicare patients. As Gray points out, “No one is expected to pay this tax; they are expected to negotiate.”
In other instances, Congress has reduced existing taxes to zero, such as when it dismantled the Affordable Care Act’s tax on individuals who do not purchase a minimum level of health insurance.
Gray further notes that the Supreme Court’s decision in McNutt could affect penalties on tax promoters, as well as firearm registration and reporting requirements for large cash or digital asset transactions and donations to nonprofits.
“Whether the Supreme Court reasons broadly or narrowly will determine whether a dispute over backyard stills will spill over into the rest of the [Internal Revenue] Code,” Gray writes.
Read the full article on Bloomberg Tax:
Supreme Court Home Distiller Tax Case Poised for a Ripple Effect
About Gray Proctor
Gray is an experienced and accomplished appellate advocate who represents clients facing both civil and criminal tax penalties. He is board-certified as an expert in appellate practice by the Florida Bar Association and accepts cases in a wide variety of disputes in addition to tax.



