Skip to main content

Abigail Burke explores the evolving legal landscape surrounding whether assets seized by the government remain taxable in an article for The CPA Journal titled “The Tax Impacts of Asset Forfeiture.”

As Abby explains, the government often relies on asset forfeiture as a means to deter wrongdoing and deprive those who break the law of the benefits of their offenses, but whether those assets continue to be taxable may depend on which process the government uses to seize them and for what purposes the assets are sold or transferred. The law in this space is still developing, with different courts and stakeholders expressing different opinions.

The IRS has distinguished between civil and criminal asset forfeitures, noting that some assets in civil forfeitures could be taxable, but arguing that in criminal forfeiture, “there is arguably a personal liability from which the taxpayer is discharged.”

The U.S. Tax Court, however, has not distinguished between civil and criminal forfeitures, particularly in cases involving the seizure of assets such as individual retirement accounts (IRAs). Because the government generally taxes distributions from IRAs, the court reasoned that disbursing IRA funds to a third party, such as the government, remained taxable and the taxpayer's responsibility.

However, the jurisprudence over the taxability of asset forfeiture was called into question following a 2025 case, Hubbard v. Commissioner, in which the Sixth Circuit Court of Appeals overturned a Tax Court ruling that an IRA distribution to the government was taxable.

The Sixth Circuit’s decision in Hubbard relied on the fact that the taxpayer’s forfeiture was not pursuant to a money judgment.

As Abby explains:

The court reasoned that “Hubbard obtained no ‘economic gains’ (that is income) when the IRS withdrew the IRA funds” because the withdrawal “did not reduce any ‘indebtedness’ that Hubbard owed the IRS.” The court commented in the opinion that “if the district court in Hubbard’s criminal case had entered a ‘personal money judgment’ against Hubbard that was collectable on all his assets, that judgment may well have created a debt.”

Abby cautions tax advisers with clients who have forfeited assets to tread carefully, and she outlines a few options for addressing forfeited assets on a tax return.

“The intersection of forfeiture and tax law is extremely complex, and CPAs must think carefully and proactively about how to handle this difficult situation,” she writes.

Read the full article:

The Tax Impacts of Asset Forfeiture

About Abigail Burke

Abby’s practice primarily focuses on white-collar defense and tax controversy. In her time at Kostelanetz, Abby has assisted in multiple high-stakes criminal matters, where her attention to detail and written advocacy have helped achieve successful outcomes.